Archive for Global Education

WorldStrides Summit on Global Awareness & Leadership

globe

Last week, our global programs director Brian and I spent two days at a WorldStrides-sponsored event in Philadelphia, at which we studied questions about optimal program design and student experience. The presenter lineup featured organization and school experts in global travel, providing a rich range of perspectives and wisdom on the topic.

Some highlights:

  • What is the overall purpose of your program? Curriculum, experience, or service?
  • What does your school community value? Is your global program aligned?
  • How much is global education represented in the rest of the school curriculum? Do students see the travel program connected to the rest of their school experience?
  • Has your school thoroughly studied student health and safety preparations and plans?
  • Do groups travel during or outside the school term?
  • Where does student leadership live in your travel program?

We have returned with a decent list of outstanding school travel programs of different types:

At UPrep, we are implementing the first large shift in our signature Global Link program in 10 years. Our new Intensive terms allow Global Link to travel during an intensive term rather than over spring break. So far, two trips have migrated into the January intensive, with plans to continue moving trips next year.

Adding a specific subject’s curriculum to the trip is a new feature of Intensive Global Link. Our first three examples are Human Rights in Colombia, Global Link American South, and Storytelling in Samoa. As a result, schools that have established strong curricular connections for global travel are of specific interest to us right now. From the above list, these include Ideaventions, Lawrenceville, and Trinity Palmer, at a minimum.

Finally, Global Education Benchmark Group (GEBG) Executive Director Clare Sisisky presented three times on insights gleaned from GEBG’s 250 member schools, including broad perspectives on global program outcomes, school partnerships, conceptual frameworks, assessment instruments, and examples from model schools.

[Photo by Juliana Kozoski on Unsplash]

Maru-a-Pula Scholars in the U.S.

2011_Botswana_-_14

Edward “Ned” Hall founded the American Friends of Maru-a-Pula in 1974, just two years after Maru-a-Pula itself opened its doors in Gaborone, Botswana. In the 40 years since, AFMAP has helped Maru-a-Pula develop into one of the best secondary schools in southern Africa. The school’s role in the region has also changed beyond its original purpose of racial justice to now include top academic performance and education for social responsibility. In recent years, MAP has extended the gift of world-class education to dozens of orphan scholars who lost their parents.

Since 1981, AFMAP has quietly played another key role in the lives of Maru-a-Pula students. A recent article from Taft Bulletin tells the story of the MAP Scholar program. Since 1981, deserving MAP IGCSE graduates have been selected to spend a senior year in top U.S. independent schools. On average, seven MAP students become U.S. scholars each year. While these schools have underwritten tuition and boarding fees, AFMAP has provided these students with a familiar face and, when needed, a helping hand.

MAP Scholars have startled and impressed their U.S. hosts with their academic preparation, leadership skills, humility, and sense of social purpose. Our students have not only completed the rigorous programs of top U.S. independent schools but have also become leaders and proceeded to top colleges and graduate programs at institutions such as Harvard, Williams, MIT, and Stanford. A number of MAP Scholars previously received Orphans and Vulnerable Children scholarships at MAP. The outstanding support of AFMAP donors has changed these deserving students’ lives.

It should not surprise you that many MAP Scholars have dedicated their lives to helping others. They have become experts in global health, medicine, finance, and East Asian studies. Four serve on the AFMAP board, including president and secretary. In my time, I have been privileged to know MAP scholars Neo, Portia, Thomas, Ernest, Urban, Lollise, MK, Kush, Mmaserame, Tumisang, and others.

I had the incredibly good luck to start my teaching career at Taft in 1991, in the company of former Maru-a-Pula teachers Emily and Gordon Jones and MAP Scholars Tebogo Phiri, Thomas Lukoma, and Urban Dabutha. I then traveled to Botswana and joined the Maru-a-Pula staff for two years. MAP has remained a vital part of my life and career to this day.

 

The Smartest Kids In the World

Each summer, U Prep faculty members read a choice of three books to kick off the professional development theme for the following academic year. This year, our professional development theme is “Teaching for Understanding,” defined as curriculum design and teaching practices that lead students to acquire deep, enduring understanding of subject matter and skills. The first book, The Smartest Kids In the World, asks what the United States high school education system can learn from comparisons to three countries: Finland, South Korea, and Poland. Written by a journalist, the book meets our summer reading criteria of readability, thoughtfulness, and connection to our professional development theme for the year.

book-photo-smartestSome authors, it seems, try to write a book from material that would have done just as well as a magazine article. The Smartest Kids In the World is no such book. Impressive in scope, Amanda Ripley explores and connects several topics worthy of a full volume. Ripley begins by explaining the origin of the PISA test, the basis for recent comparisons of student performance among different countries. In several subsequent chapters, she tells the stories of three American high school students who each study abroad for a year. The three stories weave in and out through chapters organized connected to principles from education research. Making specific connections between research and practices supports Ripley as she explores the implications of the three students’ experiences. The appendices provide information useful to parents, such as Ripley’s take on things to look for when you observe a school and what PISA reveals about beneficial parenting habits.

Ripley repeats her primary message throughout the book: national education reform is possible, because here are three countries that have made massive changes over relatively short periods of time. Finland rocketed up the standings by overhauling its teacher selection, preparation, and induction programs. Poland committed to rigor and student accountability in order to emerge from the damage wreaked by political instability. South Korea is portrayed as two systems: formal schooling that students largely ignore, plus night tutoring centers that do the real job of teaching students. Ripley, the journalist, observes, summarizes, and then concludes, lending support to her recommendations.

Ripley sees several lessons that the U.S. should learn from these three educational systems. High expectations are critical for both teachers and students. Ripley’s students find themselves behind as a result of moving from the U.S. to these countries. National testing enforces high standards, leading to rigorous study habits and high quality instruction. Each of these countries has a high-stakes, national exam toward which students are constantly working. Unlike in the U.S., the national exam has direct career implications for students, so that they have high motivation to work hard and succeed. High standards for teachers make it possible to uphold high standards for students. Finland’s teacher education programs have high entry requirements. In South Korea, a second, the most effective night tutors profit directly from these business ventures. Poland provided teachers with curricular freedom while implementing more rigorous standards.

Common Core notwithstanding, the U.S. education system is primarily directed by individual states. Can these reforms, found in other countries, work in the U.S.? Ripley finds such a state in Minnesota. This completes her argument: if three U.S. students find more rigor abroad, and a U.S. state can similarly improve, then this must be the way to go. At the same time, Ripley pulls no punches in her criticisms of the dominant mindset in U.S. education. Ripley repeatedly cites examples of a failure to commit to high standards, hold students individually accountable for their performance, and select the best teaching candidates and prepare them thoroughly for teaching.

Ripley’s argument passes the “common sense” test. High standards, teacher preparation, and accountability certainly makes a good formula for improvement in education systems. The book also serves as a useful introduction to international comparisons. As a New York Times best seller, this message has broad reach. However, her book is less useful for the purpose of making actual education reform in the U.S., as Ripley’s argument skirts a number of important additional questions required to reform education systems.

Let’s start with PISA, the foundation for these international comparisons. Does PISA predict future economic success for individuals? The path to employment in the U.S. is very different from other countries. For some industries, high school math preparation may lead directly to professional success, particularly in those professions in which accurate completion of tasks is most important. However, new, information-based industries have fueled more recent growth in the U.S. economy. Procedural, and even conceptual, mastery of high school curricula may not build the thinking skills that individuals require to be economically successful adults. Ripley does not extend her thesis to adults and their professional success.

With all of the education scholars that Ripley cites, her omission of Yong Zhao is particularly notable. Zhao also compares education systems in other countries and finds that some, like China, are actually looking to reduce their emphasis on rigor, performance, and long hours of study and emulate the U.S.’s focus on education options and creativity. While the two approaches reflect different conclusions from international comparisons, Ripley could strengthen her position by addressing Zhao’s work.

While Ripley supports her main points well with evidence, some minor points read as pure opinion. Her argument that students in other countries have gained strong conceptual mastery and critical thinking skills is not well-supported. Any standardized test is limited in its capacity to measure higher-order thinking skills such as making connections among different ideas, inventing new ideas, and identifying themes within and among disciplines. While the PISA may do a better job of assessing higher-order thinking than other tests, the format has unavoidable limitations. Ripley also does not address the subject area strengths in the U.S., for example literary analysis and writing, which typically do not receive as much attention in other countries.

U.S. education systems emphasize choice and student direction. Diverse elective course offerings are a hallmark of U.S. schools, allowing students to personalize their own education based on their interests. The emphasis on choice continues into college. Is this part of the reason why the United States has succeeded in generating dominant, new industries over time? In most other countries, students commit to a specific professional track early and subsequently lack the flexibility to shift disciplines as they learn more about themselves and as national economic needs change. Finally, Ripley’s suggestion that teacher kindness towards students undermines teaching effectiveness is suspect. While the U.S. system places the burden of motivation on individual students, and does not serve all students equally, it also offers many avenues for achievement and excellence. Many examples exist of benefits to students who have strong relationships with their teachers.

With The Smartest Kids In the World, Amanda Ripley makes an welcome contribution to popular education literature. Now the opportunity exists for U.S. education systems to give teaching higher status and support in order to achieve higher standards and student success that most would like to see.

Insurance’s Outsize Influence on Global Travel

It seems that each year, insurance requirements increasingly affect our school global programs in a way that threatens their emphasis on social responsibility and global citizenship. This year, our school cancelled its annual student trip to Colombia because our insurance company would not cover travel to a country that is on the U.S. State Department’s warning list. From the State Department:

Tens of thousands of U.S. citizens safely visit Colombia each year for tourism, business, university studies, and volunteer work. Security in Colombia has improved significantly in recent years, including in tourist and business travel destinations such as Bogota and Cartagena, but violence linked to narco-trafficking continues to affect some rural areas and parts of large cities.

For the insurance company, this is a blanket rule. If the country is on the warning list, for whatever reason and region, the company will not insure the school for travel to that country. From our point of view, no insurance results in no trip. This was difficult to swallow when we had been traveling to Colombia for years, in partnership with a local school, and in a manner that maximized student safety. It is not easy to sever the close, personal relationships among staff members of these schools for these reasons.

Presumably, the Hotchkiss suit of 2013 played a role in changing insurance company attitudes toward global student travel. One $41 million case likely had an outsize effect on their practices, and consequently, school travel abroad. On the optimistic side, a business opportunity now exists for an insurance company to design travel insurance that considers the nuances within the State Department travel warning list.

I am also seeing these effects as I organize the fifth U.S. tour of the Maru-a-Pula Marimba Band. This year, schools have inquired whether Maru-a-Pula School holds international travel insurance. I also had a college theater that we are renting require liability insurance, to protect the school in case an audience member were injured at our show. It appeared that we might have to cancel the show, until we discovered that the college also provides a one-time, $50 liability insurance purchase option. I have a hard time understanding how our $50 purchase protects the college from a million dollar lawsuit, but clearly the insurance industry is operating on its own particular economic models. Each trip, it becomes more onerous for a volunteer such as myself to bring a marvelous student marimba group from Botswana to the U.S.

Twenty years ago, independent school global travel was dominated by language study and cultural immersion to Spanish and French-speaking countries. Since then, most independent schools have completely transformed their global travel programs, updating their missions for social responsibility and global citizenship. This has resulted in travel to Asian, African, South American, and other destinations. Most destinations are selected because a school community member has a personal connection with the target country. Will insurance companies adapt to the travel patterns of independent school global programs, or will schools have to adjust their destinations to stay in line with State Department warnings?

Global Online Academy 2.0

The new Global Online Academy website includes course offerings for 2012-13. They represent a big step up in variety and sophistication over year 1. Detailed descriptions may be found here.

AN INTRODUCTION TO BIOETHICS

COMPARATIVE GOVERNMENT: CAMPAIGNS AND ELECTIONS

DECLARING OUR HUMANITY: APPLYING PHILOSOPHY TO MODERN GLOBAL ISSUES

DIGITAL PHOTOGRAPHY: GLOBAL PERSPECTIVES THROUGH THE LENS

GRASSROOTS HISTORY OF CHINA

THE HISPANIC EXPERIENCE

JAPANESE LANGUAGE THROUGH CULTURE

MEDICAL PROBLEM SOLVING

MULTIVARIABLE CALCULUS

USING GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION SYSTEMS TO SOLVE GLOBAL ISSUES

9/11

ENVIRONMENTAL ECONOMICS

FRENCH HIP-HOP

GLOBAL HEALTH

IPHONE/IPAD APP DEVELOPMENT

MEDIA STUDIES

MODERN ETHICAL DILEMMAS

URBAN STUDIES

PLAYWRITING 2.0

A Guide to Schools Considering Online Learning

NAIS recently published an Online Learning Guide, designed to help schools gain perspective and consider next steps for their considerations of online learning. Alex, Arvind, and Vinnie from EdTechTalk asked me to join their weekly radio show to discuss the report. Listen to the conversation on EdTechTalk.com.

We covered the following questions:

– Why did Catlin Gabel join the Global Online Academy?

– How do independent online school options compare, particularly in their teaching strategies?

– Can online high schools support a culture of inquiry?

– Is student-student dialogue an advantage of online learning or an obstacle to overcome?

– How does a rubric approach help schools evaluate their progress with investigating online learning?

For the second question, we compared Global Online Academy, Online School for Girls, Stanford EPGY Online High School, and George Washington University Online High School.

Botswana Trip Recap

13 students and two teachers visited Botswana from 19 June to 7 July. The trip achieved its goal of providing direct service to HIV/AIDS organizations, introducing students to Botswana culture, and strengthening the relationship between Catlin Gabel and Maru-a-Pula schools. The trip blog chronicles the day-by-day details. This post summarizes some of the trip themes.

Exchange Students
Five Batswana students have attended both Maru-a-Pula and Catlin Gabel through an exchange program. Three of them were actively involved in the Catlin Gabel trip. They provided some of the most personal experiences of the trip, describing their difficulties integrating into U.S. culture and providing a unique look into their families’ lives in Botswana. MK took us to her family’s cattlepost (ranch) for a sleepover, traditional meal, and stargazing. Mmaserame took us to both her father’s village for a thorough traditional village experience and to her mother’s family’s house in Gaborone for lunch and an amazing oral history telling. Our students also met next year’s Maru-a-Pula exchange student for Catlin Gabel, which should greatly ease her transition into the school.

HIV/AIDS Service Work
We had some difficulty planning service activities in detail before the trip, but a lot fell into place once we arrived there. The Botswana-Baylor Centre was great. Peace Corps volunteer Peter took especially linked us up with a number of activities — painting a mural for the teen center (visited by Michelle Obama), designing math activities for pre-appointment playtimes, and supporting the Saturday teen club gathering. Maru-a-Pula hosted an evening with Dr. Ava Avalos from the Ministry of Health and Thobo Mogojwe from PING (Positive Innovation for the Next Generation). We also grew to appreciate the presence of HIV in everyday life across the country, from talk of the new medical school to village trainings for HIV+ people. We toured a new health clinic in Thabala distributed NikeRED laces to youth in Gumare.

Some students wished that we could have provided more meaningful support to HIV organizations than playing with students and painting murals. We concluded that the organizations’ volunteers and staff had far more expertise providing counseling and treatment than did our group, and we were best placed supporting ancillary services instead. We did wish that we could have had more informal conversations with teen peers about HIV and AIDS in Botswana — they may have been instructive to both our students and the youth in Botswana.

A Cross-section of Life in Botswana
Our students got to experience a non-touristic cross-section of ordinary life in Botswana, pretty rare for a visiting group. In two weeks’ time, we visited independent and government schools, internationally-funded health clinics and government hospitals and clinics, cities and villages, the capital city and very remote villages, the edge of the Kalahari and part of the Okavango swamps, a basket weaver co-op, and of course a classic African wildlife experience. We owe this comprehensive tour of the country to our NGO and alumni contacts.

Student Development and Global Service
This was a little tougher. All of our students got so much out of this trip, but sometimes we saw students miss a great opportunity to learn even more. Students were reticent to initiate conversations without ample support structures. The “Catlin bubble” became portable, and students talked about life back home as much as they immersed themselves in Botswana life. We trip leaders were caught between recognizing the students’ development as adolescents and wanting to see them fully engage with the local culture.

This global trip accomplished so much for our school within a short period of time. Perhaps we will move a step closer to fully celebrating our international students and our school’s relationship with a school in Botswana as a result.

In Botswana

This blog is on hiatus while I lead a school trip to Botswana. The students are blogging the trip. Kassblog will return July 9.

Botswana Trip Curricular Goals

Source: cordelia_persen on Flickr

We leave for Botswana in two weeks. What curricular goals have we realized so far, and what remains to accomplish?

Collaborations with discipline-based classes
We (the two trip leaders) proposed to invite teachers to include the topic of HIV/AIDS in Botswana in their classes. Our method was simple: we raised the opportunity with teachers by email and impromptu, in-person conversations. To our pleasure, a half-dozen teachers responded with interest.

Pathogens and Parasites students wrote a guide to malaria and HIV/AIDS in Botswana for trip families. I presented some basic facts about the country and then organized the students into groups to co-write this document.

Statistics students analyzed data on AIDS prevalence in Botswana.

Second grade students wrote introductory letters (w/photos) to primary students in Gumare, in support of the yearlong theme of global awareness.

Media Arts students created short films from poems that Maru-a-Pula students wrote.

Advanced Biology students studied the intricacies of the immune system, or viruses and on the specifics of the HIV virus and it’s effect on infected humans.

Collaborations with co-curricular programs
We hold an annual diversity conference, planned and led by students. One trip participant shared excerpts from a book on HIV and AIDS in Botswana and shared clips from a film then facilitated a discussion of both.

Two teachers work with students in the Global Citizens Club to offer a series of film viewings throughout the year. The Viewfinder Global Film Series included the film Miss HIV, introduced and facilitated by two trip participants.

Non-collaborative activities with curricular links
While the curriculum of trip preparation remains firmly embedded in the school’s co-curricular program, some conversations demonstrated links with the school’s curricular program.

Trip participants spoke with various HIV/AIDS experts about Botswana.

Cascade AIDS Project
Botswana-Harvard AIDS Partnership
Médecins Sans Frontières
Providence Health
Botswana-Baylor Pediatric AIDS Initiative.

The trip group organized and delivered a presentation at Upper School assembly, including dramatic role play.

Trip participants organized on-campus fundraising events to benefit support organizations in Botswana.

Trip group read and discussed Saturday Is for Funerals.

Miss HIV

On the one hand, Miss HIV provides detailed insight into the personal side of HIV/AIDS in Botswana and Uganda. Interview subjects describe their journeys through testing, illness, treatment, and publicly revealing their status. The filmmakers share footage of funerals, burials, church ceremonies, and the 2006 International AIDS Conference. We have found it valuable to gain insight into the personal dimensions of the HIV/AIDS epidemic in Botswana.

On the other hand, the film is also a fascinating study in how to make a propaganda vehicle. It begins as a “balanced” presentation of competing western ideological views of how to best fight HIV/AIDS in sub-Saharan Africa. On one side, we have local policy created in Uganda and based on abstinence, faithfulness, and use of condoms. On the other, we have a liberal, western policy based on the San Francisco gay experience, emphasizing human rights, and implemented in Botswana. The stigma of being HIV+ is presented as a key obstacle to overcome. The film is pretty clear so far.

The middle of the film is confusing (deliberately?), presenting several contradictory ideas in quick succession. Western policy does not support abstinence education, but then here is a shot of George W. Bush signing for millions for abstinence. Bill Gates is booed for supporting abstinence and then cheered for acknowledging the limits of abstinence policy. One speaker bemoans the lack of support for women’s rights organizations, then another speaker chides Mr. Gates for (somehow) supporting prostitution. The Miss HIV Stigma-free Pageant is alternately celebrated for battling stigma and criticized for sexualizing a public heath crisis.

Near the end, the film suddenly crystallizes its argument, “saving” viewers from their confused state. Abstinence education has worked in Uganda, and sexually permissive policies have failed in Botswana. A church minister and two individuals who cherish abstinence are the key figures in this part of the film.

This tidy conclusion overlooks some key facts:

  • The ABC approach was popularized in Botswana in the 1990’s. (source)
  • Uganda’s success resulted from a number of factors, not just abstinence. (source)
  • Uganda has a mixture of substrains HIV-1A, 1C, and 1D (source). In Botswana, HIV-1C is responsible for nearly all infections (source). It is more difficult to prevent new infections with HIV-1C.

For each powerful voice that Miss HIV shares in the fight against HIV/AIDS, it leaves out another.

  • Human rights organizations have expressed concern about President Museveni’s restrictions on homosexuals and democratic processes. (source)
  • Social engineering is extremely difficult and certainly not formulaic.
  • The film does not include interviews with ministry of health officials in either country.

Miss HIV shares rare, first-hand footage of HIV and AIDS in Uganda and Botswana but ultimately presents a one-sided conclusion.