Tag Archive for laptop-program

Catlin Gabel 1:1 Laptop Program Report

The third Upper School laptop program survey in eight years attempts to discover the uses of laptop computers in the instructional program, the effects of laptop computing on study, communication, and school culture, and levels of satisfaction with the program.

Key Findings

Laptop computers are associated with positive effects on organization, writing skills, and learning environment design.

Laptop computers are associated with negative effects on attention.

Students use computers more often for homework than during class.

Students use computers most in English, science, history, modern languages, digital arts, and computer science classes.

Teachers expressed concern more often than students about negative effects on face-to-face communication.

Teachers and students varied in opinion on the effects on school culture.

Parents are generally satisfied with the school’s laptop program.

iPad: Finding the Grey

Here I am at 30,000 feet, blogging on the school iPad with GoGo wireless. How far these technologies have come in such a short time! I have previously stated that the iPad is poor for content creation, but now I am beginning to see the promise. I am finding the grey space between evangelist and curmudgeon.

By far the best feature is the long battery life, able to last a cross-country plane flight or a full day of class use. No device is effective when it’s out of juice. The keyboard is just tolerable if I place the iPad in landscape orientation. I’m probably typing at 20 words a minute.

I recently read the accreditation report of a peer school that is rolling out a 1:1 iPad program. That’s one iPad for each student in the school. Last week, my reaction to this news was surprise and lack of understanding. It’s highly unlikely that we would do such a thing at our school. Having learned more about their school, I can see the rationale now.

1. They are committing to replace texts with electronic content as much as possible. The iPad is best equipped for content consumption, so this fits great. Presumably, they have strong teacher support for this.

2. They are interested in better supporting students by presenting materials in multiple media (another advantage over print).

3. They are simultaneously seeking a new learning management system platform. The iPad rollout will take place along with a new platform for delivering instructional content and working together.

4. They have a smaller budget than most laptop schools. A 1:1 laptop program is likely out of reach, so it does not make sense to speculate how much better laptops are than iPads. The real question is how much better iPads are compared with laptop carts and shared desktops.

5. Similarly, they may not want to increase tech staff. The iPad lends itself to a distributed management model. Load them up once and then let go of the management responsibility. So far at least, the iPad appears to suffer few weaknesses compared to a device with a full operating system.

6. They are seeking distinctive programs to help attract students within a competitive independent school market.

7. They are timing the rollout to coincide with iPad 2 (good move!). They should avoid the limitations of the first version, gain a camera and microphone, and perhaps lower the price, plus whatever other improvements Apple has cooked up!

I still have questions about feasibility of this program. Can students really write essays and complete assessments using the on-screen keyboard? How will the school deal with the lack of a central file storage system? Are enough teachers committed to developing sufficient electronic content? I look forward to seeing how it goes.

Firmly On the Ground

Do you run a 1:1 student laptop program? Do your teachers and students do all of their work in the cloud, without any local system configuration? I have two questions for you.

What do you do when no cloud equivalent exists for a desktop application?
How do you provision network, antivirus, and security configurations?

Our desktop applications include:

  • Fathom
  • Geometer’s Sketchpad
  • ComicLife
  • Inspiration
  • LoggerPro
  • Flip4Mac
  • iBackup
  • Microsoft Office
  • Adobe Creative Suite

System configuration includes:

  • 802.1x system profile or WEP pre-shared key
  • Custom machine name (for network identification)
  • DHCP reservation (to assist with network identity)
  • Server certificate for Global Address List lookups
  • Sophos antivirus client
  • SafeConnect (network access control) client
  • Altiris (inventory and remote control) client
  • Allow remote administration via Apple Remote Desktop
  • Local administrator account for Apple Remote Desktop access
  • Apple administrator account to facilitate Apple repairs
  • Root user for some remote tasks